Logo

Avatar

usability in the wee hours

Intolerance for identical elements

Run away from elements on a single web page that have similar names. Rename them. People get confused. No, really.

Take the Wordpress upload pane for example. You have a tab and a button with the same label - “Browse” (for that matter the “Upload” is doubled too). People get confused. I’ve seen it at least thrice. They click on the tab when they really want to choose a local file to upload. Or choose a file and then hit the “Upload” tab, expecting the file to be uploaded. Yes, tech savvy people won’t get confused, but most people will.

Avoid duplicates, even in the face of the “Obvious”. People trust the labels in the virtual environment. They guide them. In the real world they know that if they see a sign Exit on two doors both doors will most probably lead out. They know the laws and common habits of this world, so they don’t feel the pressure of choosing the wrong door. Novice users feel the Internet as a place, not a method for accomplishing something. So uncertain of the rules “here” they’ll play by the ones they’re already comfortable with. And usually they won’t learn from their mistakes on their own. They don’t feel such a big difference between a tab or a button. After all, both have the same labels.

We can easily name the Browse tab “Attached files” or something like that. The “Browse” can become “Choose a local file” or even “Choose a file”. The upload tab can transform to “Attach a file” and the button can be left untouched. “Browse all” will look much better as “All attached files” or “All files”. These are just quick thoughts. If you put more time into that better suggestions will emerge for sure. What do you think?

Popularity: 30% [?]

Reply to “Intolerance for identical elements”

Note: This post is over a year old. You may want to check later in this blog to see if there is new information relevant to your comment.

By submitting a comment here you grant this site a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution.

Before you go

Going so soon? Why not take a look at some more popular posts.

Sharing is caring

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 License, except when it's noted otherwise.


Browserific

Please don't use Internet Explorer and help the standardization of the Internet. Try some other browsers - Firefox, Safari, Opera. You may like one of those (or another) better!